Team Harpy comprises Lisa Rabey (@ByShieldMaiden), Nina de Jesus (@satifice), and, later, Sarah Houghton (The Librarian In Black, @TheLiB) pictured top right. Ms. Houghton became the team treasurer of online collections. "Sarah Houghton is running the legal defense fund for the sake of transparency and openness. (link)" I believe she traveled to Canada to speak against Joe Murphy (@LibraryFuture), the victim of the fake, phoney, and fraudulent Team Harpy.
This kind of fakery harms true efforts to stop sexual harassment. And I'm not the only one saying so:
Correct, Mr. Cornwall, and that's why I started Librarians.cc and Library Journal has written about it (link). I'm trying to build a repository of information.I would also strongly advise against using this episode to proclaim that sexual harassment is not an issue within ALA. Hopefully we as an organization can constructively address this issue though [sic] better documentation and dialog. - Daniel Cornwall, Alaska Chapter ALA Councilor
Just look how bad this #TeamHarpy debacle is:
I made false and damaging comments about librarian Joe Murphy for which I would like to apologize. ....
... I posted tweets that referenced librarian Joe Murphy implying without a basis in fact that he was a sexual predator. These unsubstantiated statements gained wide attention and caused Mr. Murphy significant damage.
My intention in posting these tweets was to draw attention to the issue of sexual harassment of female librarians in the profession. My statements were made carelessly, and were not based on facts. I have never observed Mr. Murphy sexually harass or exhibit sexually predatory behavior. ....
I was ill prepared for the damaging impact that these unfair statements would have. I wholly retract my statements and unreservedly apologize to Mr. Murphy for the significant damage I have caused to his personal and professional reputation.
I strongly encourage those who aligned with #teamharpy and decided to attack Mr. Murphy to cease to continue to defame or disparage him. ....That is by Lisa Rabey of Team Harpy. I have to use ellipses since Ms. Rabey successfully forced me to censor out information on sexual harassment here. Team Harpy apparently was always interested in themselves, not in stopping the sexual harassment of librarians.
What a disgrace.
Where does Joe Murphy go to get his reputation back (link)?
Even I became a target of Team Harpy's spin machine, e.g.:
Interesting the plantiff in #teamharpy, SafeLibraries, & Steven Abrams is on the list but not me nor @satifice. @jacobsberg @MattAndersonUT
— Shield Maiden (@byshieldmaiden) December 16, 2014
Then both Joe Murphy and I got a threat:
Then the free speech librarians like Ingrid Henny Abrams (@MagpieLibrarian) sent out the message to #TeamHarpy to block me, complete with false claims of homophobia, and almost 100 have, all because I drew parallels to my being sued for defamation for exposing Gay Hate @ Your Library (link):
And Team Harpy member Sarah Houghton? She is ALA's top Internet filtering expert. She says Internet filters do not work even though everyone knows they work really well now (link). ALA just published a heavily-promoted report on ten years since CIPA called, "Fencing Out Knowledge: Impacts of CIPA 10 Years Later (link)," and how filters do not work, all based on Team Harpy member Sarah Houghton's research, if you look in the footnotes. And now Sarah Houghton is a proven faker. I've always said that report was false as it was based on Sarah Houghton's outdated findings. I could never have imagined the extent of the fakery. And yes, Team Harpy's Sarah Houghton is also helping to fund the defamation suit against me. So while complaining about a supposed SLAPP suit against her Team Harpy members, Sarah Houghton's funding a SLAPP suit against me (link).
Anyway, I am trying to help sexually harassed librarians and I am asking people not to be discouraged by Team Harpy's fakery. Please contact me if you need help or if you want to write anonymously here at Librarians.cc.
And I see readers of #GamerGate are interested in what I'm writing. Welcome.
— Targa (@astragaal) March 26, 2015
NOTE ADDED 28 MARCH 2015:
This story has gone international. See:
- "#TeamHarpy: Another Ugly Story of 'Progressive' Vigilantism," by Allum Bokhari, Breitbart, 27 March 2015.
I commented there as follows:
Missing from this story is the third member of TeamHarpy, Sarah Houghton, calling herself the "Librarian in Black." Interestingly, the Librarian in Black got involved in this matter to the point of essentially becoming part of TeamHarpy. And we know what happened to TeamHarpy. And the Librarian in Black is the American Library Association’s [ALA] leading expert on library filtering software and she says filters don't work and should not be used. And your local library might not use filters as a direct result of this proven liar's false claims.
This intentional destruction of a man's career over false allegations for a year is in part the Librarian in Black's doing. It was all false. That has got to be very bad for Librarian in Black's credibility. And she's ALA's leading expert saying library filters do not work. That has got to be very bad for ALA's credibility.
They can spin it all they want but if this were a court of law opposing counsel would tear her to pieces. I know, I've investigated experts myself and they lost all credibility as a result of what I uncovered.
Of course library media will do all they can to ignore how ALA's filtering expert has completely destroyed her credibility. I mean this is a national story now, this TeamHarpy debacle.
What a complete debacle.
When ALA is on your local library, in its anything-goes policy based on ALA's “Library Bill of Rights,” now you know ALA’s top expert supporting the claim that library filters do no work is one of the TeamHarpy liars who destroyed a man’s career. They lied there and they are lying about filters not working when everyone now knows they work well. See “FCC: Filters Work, Communities Should Decide, Libraries Should Revisit CIPA” http://safelibraries.blogspot.com/2014/08/visser.html
Don’t let a TeamHarpy liar influence your public library’s following the law by filtering out p0rn, since libraries are for the use and benefit of the community by law, and that precludes p0rn, no matter what ALA and its TeamHarpy liar-expert says.
My opinion, of course. I have to say that so I don't get sued by the self-arrogated free speech police, again. Contact me for help cleaning out the p0rn from your local library.
URL of this opinion:
Where do you stand on gamer gate? Do you think all women are making up sexual harassment claims or did you just think this case was suspicious? If it was just this case what led you to feel that way? I'm genuinely curious, I don't know any of these people and am not trying to be inflammatory. Also where did your passion for getting the porn out libraries come from?ReplyDelete
I don't know #GamerGate well enough to have a "stand."Delete
What I think about this case is irrelevant as 2 of the 3 admitted it was faked; the third remains silent and is ALA's top expert falsely claiming library filters do not work, which is likely why she remains silent and obviously wants it to disappear.
I have no "passion for getting the porn out libraries." Porn is not the issue.
The issue is the American Library Association knowingly and intentionally flat out lies to communities to fool them into violating their own laws, and many people are being harmed as a direct result.
I think ALA lying to communities is wrong. I try to provide information of a counterbalancing nature by pointing out both the truth, backed up by reliable sources, and exactly how ALA misleads, also backed up by reliable sources. Did you know, for example, that the author of the Children's Internet Protection Act said, in essence, ALA misleads a third of American communities into following ALA's own ACLU-engendered diktat and not the law? And I have every right to report that ALA/ACLU is doing that, do I not?